Electricity bills for Tucson-area residents are about to climb — and a contentious debate over how future rate hikes get decided may be just getting started. The Arizona Corporation Commission has voted 4-1 to approve a 10% rate increase for Tucson Electric Power customers, with new rates set to take effect December 1.
On average, residential customers will see their monthly bills rise by roughly 9.4%, bringing a typical bill to around $150. The decision arrived just two weeks after the U.S. midterm elections, during which the rising cost of electricity was a prominent concern for voters across Arizona and the country.
A New Formula for Future Rate Increases
Beyond the immediate rate hike, the commission also approved TEP’s proposed Annual Rate Adjustment Mechanism, known as ARAM — a mathematical formula the utility says will streamline how future rate changes are reviewed and approved. Supporters argue the approach creates more predictability and helps avoid sudden bill spikes.
Commission Chairman Nick Myers outlined the case for the formula:
“The ARAM method allows for reduced regulatory lag, reduced rate shock to customers, while giving the Commission real world data and clear off-ramps to financially protect customers.”
Commissioner Rachel Walden echoed that position, saying the mechanism would benefit vulnerable households in particular:
“I think that the annual review and adjustment will promote gradualism and promote more regulatory certainty, especially for low income families.”
Opponents Raise Transparency Concerns
Not everyone was convinced. Nearly all parties who intervened in the rate case — including the U.S. Department of Defense — raised objections to the formula approach, citing concerns about reduced transparency in future rate-setting decisions.
Lea Márquez Peterson, the lone dissenting vote and the only Tucson-based commissioner on the panel, opposed both the formula and the rate increase. She warned of long-term consequences for customers:
“Compounding annual increases will harm customers and are more likely to occur than rate decreases. Further, the ARAM protocols provide a limited and inadequate timeframe for review by parties and the commission.”
Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes was sharply critical of the commission’s decision, arguing ratepayers were shortchanged:
“This decision is a bad deal for ratepayers. Instead of saving customers $148 million per year, as my Office’s expert witness suggested, the ACC has chosen unnecessary rate increases and electric bill instability for TEP’s customers.”
Lessons From a Similar Formula Already in Use
The ARAM approval at TEP follows a similar formula mechanism the commission previously approved for UNS Gas, a utility that shares a parent company with TEP. During the TEP proceedings, commissioners received updates on how the UNS Gas formula has been playing out in practice.
A recent UNS filing indicates that the formula would push the typical residential gas bill up 4.6% compared to last year. However, the Residential Utility Consumer Office — a state agency that advocates for utility customers — says it has not been able to independently verify those figures.
Cynthia Zwick, RUCO’s director, described the challenges her office has encountered:
“We haven’t been able to determine the rate impacts for example, or verify that the information that we have received is accurate.”
Zwick added that the compressed annual filing timelines have made thorough review increasingly difficult.
Formula-based rate mechanisms are also at the center of the ongoing Arizona Public Service rate case, where a final decision is expected next month. That case, along with the TEP vote, has put utility rate transparency squarely in the spotlight for Arizona regulators and consumers alike.
For more on related Arizona energy and utility news, see recent reporting on ethics disputes among Arizona utility regulators, how some Arizona utilities are turning to underground water to cope with Colorado River cuts, the impact of drought on record-low hydropower output across the Southwest, earlier calls by a solar group asking for a delay ahead of the TEP hearing, and the APS parent company’s $430 million in Q3 profits.