Wisconsin Voters Are Using the Ballot Box to Fight Back Against PFAS Contamination

When voters head to the polls in Wisconsin this election season, they're carrying more than their civic duty — many are carrying real anger about what's coming out of their taps. In communities across northeast Wisconsin, the fight over PFAS-contaminated groundwater has become a defining test of whether elected officials are truly accountable to the people who put them in office.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency

In northeast Wisconsin, PFAS-contaminated drinking water has become one of the defining issues shaping how voters evaluate candidates heading into this election cycle — and community members are making sure their elected officials know it. For residents like Marinette advocate Andi Rich, the question of who sits in the statehouse or Congress is no longer abstract: it’s a matter of whether the water coming out of their taps is safe to drink.

Rich has spent years tracking the latest research on so-called “forever chemicals” — perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances, or PFAS — and pushing candidates at every level to take the issue seriously. She makes no secret of her frustration when politicians fall short.

“It is a complicated issue, but it’s frustrating that the people who were put in charge to figure it out … are failing to even understand the issue well enough to know how to do anything about it,”

said Rich, a former candidate for the state Assembly.

That kind of voter pressure is reshaping the political landscape in Wisconsin. This fall, candidates in both state and national races are being pushed — by constituents like Rich — to take clear positions on PFAS regulations, groundwater standards, and polluter accountability. Clean water, it turns out, is a powerful motivator at the ballot box.

What Voters Are Dealing With

PFAS chemicals are used in everything from firefighting foam and nonstick cookware to carpeting and personal care products. They don’t break down in the environment or in the human body, which is why scientists call them forever chemicals. According to the EPA, PFAS have been linked to health issues including certain cancers, liver damage, thyroid disease, and developmental delays in children.

In Marinette County, PFAS contamination linked to Johnson Controls and its subsidiary Tyco Fire Products’ Marinette Fire Training Facility has spread into groundwater that residents rely on for drinking. And the problem is growing. According to Rich, biosolids containing PFAS were spread on surrounding lands, allowing the chemicals to leach into groundwater and migrate into new areas — including waterways that feed into the bay of Green Bay.

The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources has confirmed that the contaminated zone has expanded. During a July public listening session — itself a sign of the civic pressure residents have applied — DNR experts addressed the scope of the problem directly.

“The groundwater impacted by PFAS is extensive in this area and actions available to clean up PFAS will take a long time to achieve results,”

said Alyssa Sellwood, DNR project manager for remediation and redevelopment.

A Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources study found that 71% of 450 shallow private drinking-water wells sampled in 2022 contained at least one detectable PFAS compound — a statistic that has fueled voters’ demands for action.

Voters Are Holding Candidates Accountable

The Northeast Wisconsin News Lab sent a general election questionnaire to state candidates this September, and every candidate who responded agreed that PFAS is a serious issue in Wisconsin. That kind of unanimity — rare in today’s polarized political climate — reflects just how much community organizing and voter engagement has elevated this issue.

Bipartisan pressure from constituents has produced real legislative results. State Sen. Eric Wimberger, R-Gillett, rewrote PFAS legislation in 2024 and 2025 specifically to win Democratic support, with Assembly Rep. Jeff Mursau, R-Crivitz, co-authoring the 2025 bill. The effort worked: in April, Gov. Tony Evers signed into law two new PFAS statutes that created a state PFAS trust fund with approximately $133 million in grants for cleanup and remediation — a direct result of sustained voter pressure forcing cooperation across party lines.

But advocates and observers say the new laws, while meaningful, are only a first step. Rich and other local clean water activists are continuing to push candidates to commit to state groundwater limits for PFAS and to support banning products that contain these chemicals. They see elections as one of their most powerful tools for driving that change.

The trust voters place in government institutions is also at stake. When contamination spreads, wells fail, and water bills spike — and when solutions feel slow or inadequate — public confidence in elected officials erodes. Community members who have attended DNR listening sessions, responded to candidate questionnaires, and organized locally are doing exactly what a healthy democracy depends on: demanding answers and holding decision-makers accountable through civic participation.

The Real Cost of Contaminated Water

For some communities, the response to PFAS threats has already meant dramatic changes — and sticker shock. Officials in Green Bay and the Central Brown County Water Authority have begun selling treated Lake Michigan water to neighboring communities previously dependent on deep wells.

The village of Pulaski’s experience is a cautionary tale about the financial burden that falls on ordinary residents when contamination forces infrastructure decisions. After years of relying on deep wells that produced water discolored by iron and other minerals, the village board voted to purchase drinking water from the city of Green Bay. Water rates are expected to rise by as much as 230%.

Board Chair Keith Chambers explained that the board weighed its options carefully, including drilling new deep wells and adding PFAS filtration — but neither option offered an affordable guarantee of clean water long-term.

“We did not have any PFAS, but that can change in a heartbeat. Some could start leaching in. The DNR might change their threshold limits, or the EPA. You could have perfectly good water one day and the next day, they’re telling you it’s bad,”

Chambers said.

The project — 6.5 miles of 20-inch pipe and two new buildings — was complicated by post-COVID supply chain problems and rising construction costs. The quarterly water bill for 10,000 gallons is expected to jump from roughly $151 to $351, with ratepayers covering most of the cost. Chambers noted that a new deep well would have cost an estimated $20 million, while the Green Bay water connection came in just over $16 million, with grants from the DNR and the city of Green Bay helping offset some expenses.

“Now there are a lot of people who are angry that we didn’t put it to a referendum,”

Chambers said.

“I’m a big man, so it’s hard to tar and feather me, but if they could, they would.”

His candid admission points to a broader tension in how communities navigate PFAS: the decisions are expensive, the timelines are long, and voters want more say. Meanwhile, new deep wells installed on private properties in limited areas have drawn their own complaints — the water from depths exceeding 500 feet can contain naturally occurring contaminants like radium and strontium.

“The water from that depth in this area can be very hard and contain naturally occurring contaminants like radium and strontium, which require treatment to lower the concentrations to levels that are safe to drink,”

Sellwood said.

What Comes Next — And Why Your Vote Matters

Wisconsin’s Natural Resources Board has already passed PFAS limits for community drinking water matching the federal standards set in April 2024. The board is now expected to take up groundwater standards — a step that would directly affect private well owners across the state. Proposed limits align closely with neighboring Illinois and are stricter than Michigan’s current standards.

Whether those standards become reality — and how quickly polluters are held accountable — will depend in large part on who Wisconsin voters send to the statehouse and to Washington. For residents like Andi Rich, that connection between the ballot box and the water tap is not abstract. It is immediate, personal, and urgent. Staying informed about how candidates plan to address PFAS contamination is one of the most concrete ways Wisconsin voters can protect both their health and their democratic voice.