Gas prices remain a flashpoint in Wisconsin’s governor’s race, and one Republican candidate thinks the answer might be hiding in plain sight — at a refinery along Lake Superior. But energy economists say the math doesn’t quite add up the way politicians might hope.
U.S. Rep. Tom Tiffany, the Republican candidate for Wisconsin governor, is pushing for the expansion of the state’s only oil refinery as a way to cut dependence on Middle Eastern oil. The facility in question is the Canadian-owned Cenovus Energy refinery in Superior, which Tiffany called a valuable resource with untapped potential. Energy experts at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, however, say expanding the refinery would do little to shield Wisconsin consumers from volatile global fuel prices.
Tiffany, a Republican from Minocqua, made his case clearly:
“I think we should be looking at trying to encourage them to expand, produce more gasoline and diesel fuel here in Wisconsin, in America, so we’re not in this position where we’re dependent on the Middle East.”
It’s a straightforward-sounding proposal — but the realities of how oil markets work complicate the picture significantly.
What the Superior Refinery Actually Does
Wisconsin produces none of its own fossil fuels and relies entirely on imports of oil and gas. The crude oil that flows into the Superior refinery arrives from Canada and North Dakota via Enbridge’s mainline pipeline system — not from the Middle East.
According to federal data, the refinery has the capacity to produce nearly 50,000 barrels per day of heavy fuel oils, asphalt, and liquified petroleum gas. Historically, it has produced around 17,500 barrels per day of gasoline. To put that in perspective, Wisconsin’s total gasoline consumption in 2024 was 163,000 barrels per day — nearly 6.8 million gallons every single day.
Corbett Grainger, an energy economist at UW-Madison, acknowledged that expansion could shift where some of that fuel is produced, but said it wouldn’t solve the underlying problem:
“If we’re thinking of expanding capacity at that refinery in Superior, that could affect where we’re producing some of the fuel that we’re consuming here, but it certainly wouldn’t eliminate our exposure to global oil prices.”
Why Global Events Drive Your Gas Bill
The core issue, experts say, is that oil is not a local commodity — it’s a global one. The current driver of elevated gas prices in the U.S. is the ongoing American conflict with Iran, which has led to ongoing attacks in the Strait of Hormuz. That waterway handles one-fifth of the world’s oil and gas supply. When tensions flare there, crude oil prices rise globally — and pump prices follow everywhere, including Wisconsin.
Greg Nemet, an energy expert and public affairs professor at UW-Madison, explained why no single refinery can change that dynamic:
“We’re linked to the rest of the world, whether our refinery is the size it is now or bigger in the future. The prices that we pay for gasoline, for diesel, are affected by world events, and there’s no way getting around that as long as we’re continuing to use those products. Really, the only way to get around it is to use less of them.”
Grainger echoed the point, noting that while energy security is worth discussing, the impact of a single refinery expansion deserves careful scrutiny:
“I do think energy security is a legitimate concern that we should discuss, but I think we need to be careful about what refining capacity on its own, especially thinking about one refinery in Wisconsin, can actually accomplish.”
The Broader Political Picture
Tiffany’s Democratic opponent in the governor’s race is Milwaukee County Executive David Crowley, whose campaign did not respond to a request for comment on the refinery proposal. Crowley has criticized Tiffany for voting five times against U.S. House resolutions that would have directed President Donald Trump to end the use of U.S. forces against Iran.
Tiffany has said Trump has the authority to declare war but would need congressional approval to deploy ground troops. He told reporters last month that the U.S. should exit Iran. On one point, both candidates agree: they support a repeal of the state law that sets minimum gas prices.
When asked about expansion plans, Cenovus — the Canadian company that owns the Superior refinery — did not respond directly. Instead, a company spokesperson referred questions to the American Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturers (AFPM). An AFPM spokesperson pushed back on the idea that more domestic production would fix the price problem:
“We produce more fuel in the United States than we consume, and our refineries are running all-out to keep Americans supplied and the global economy moving despite major disruptions and actual fuel shortages in other parts of the world.”
That statement is backed by federal data. Last year, U.S. oil production surged to a new annual record of 13.6 million barrels per day. Yet exports have also grown substantially over the past decade, following Congress lifting a ban on crude oil exports and increasing global demand.
Most domestic crude is refined at U.S. facilities alongside imported oil. However, some refineries — including the one in Superior — are specifically designed to refine heavier crude oils from Canada and other sources, making them only partially interchangeable with facilities set up for lighter domestic crude.